Irish Supreme Court Says Sperm Donor is Legal Dad: Will the U.S. Follow Suit?

  By Lori Andrews

Last week, the Supreme Court of Ireland stunned the reproductive technology community by holding that a sperm donor had legal rights as a father.  Four of the five justices wrote separate opinions as to why an agreement in advance not to be a donor did not prevent the sperm donor from asserting parental rights.

The case, J. McD v. PL and BM, involved a Lesbian couple who chose a friend as a sperm donor.  He signed an agreement stating that the female couple were the parents and he would have a role akin to that of a "favourite uncle."  When he sought a greater relationship, a lower court ruled against him.  But the Supreme Court of Ireland held that he could assert his legal rights. 

The reasoning used by the various justices was sweeping and could be applied to any situation of donor insemination, not just those involving nontraditional family structures.  Chief Justice Murray, for example, seemed to compare the sperm donor, McD., to a biological mother who gives her child up for adoption. Murray indicated that the sperm donor’s consent to relinquish parental rights before the child is born is suspect. Murray said that a sperm donor, "when faced after birth with the reality of a child… may, quite forseeably, experience strong natural feelings of parental empathy and identity which may overcome previous perceptions…arrived at in the more abstract situation before the child was even conceived….  [A] change of heart may be, as it was in this case, an event which raises issues as to whether in the interests of the child access or guardianship ought to be granted to the father."

In the United States, as in Ireland, the biological parents of a child cannot create a private contract which denies either parent's rights or responsibilities.  To get around the legal precedent that private agreements are non-binding, most American states have adopted sperm donor statutes, generally addressed to married couples, which hold that the consenting husband of the woman who is inseminated is the legal father.  There are several loopholes in the American jurisprudence, however.  A handful of states do not have statutes at all.  Some of the statutes only say the husband is the father and the donor is not, but others just say that the husband is the father without specifically cutting off the donor's parental rights.  Some terminate the donor’s parental rights only when a married woman is inseminated, not a single woman.  So, litigation in which a sperm donor asserts his rights is still a possibility in some states.  In the absence of specific statutory guidance that is directly on point, an American court, like the Irish one, would probably turn to the "best interest of the child" standard. 

And changing cultural norms might convince an American court that children have a right to learn the identity of their biological fathers, the sperm donors.  In the Irish decision, Justice Fennelly pointed out, "Scientific advances have made us aware that our unique genetic make-up derives from two independent but equally unique sources of genetic material. That is the aspect of the welfare of the child which arises."

So, ironically, even at the same time that reproductive technology is making it unnecessary for parents to have a biological connection to their child, genetic technology is telling children that biology matters.  And courts may be willing to grant a sperm donor rights, not just for the benefit of the donor, but for the benefit of the child. 

Comments

[Christian Louboutin Outlet]

Yes.agree. If its a mans sperm, its his child! Whether its from sperm donor, or by sex it doesnt matterDo’t delay anything that adds laughter and joy to your life and families;let's tell our families and friends

[hampers]

Quote "...children have a right to learn the identity of their biological fathers..." This is one basic rights of children. However, if the father wants to remain anonymous, his request should be respected.

[A Blog About Loans Involving Guarantors]

It's a tricky one to look at isn't it. If you're going to donate sperm then you really need to realise that how you feel about it will most likely change once your baby is born!

I think the problem here lies in the fact that the donor was aware of the whole situation. Which probably isn't a bad thing.

[keylogger Mac]

This is my first time i visit here. I found interesting things to many in your blog, mostly to the debate.

[keylogger Mac]

This is my first time i visit here. I found interesting things to many in your blog, mostly to the debate.

[Thomas Sabo Neue Kollektion 2011]

I hope you continue to update, I will continue to pay attention to it,I like yours~

[Fashion news]

my God, i thought you were going to chip in with some decisive insght at the end there, not leave it with �we leave it to you to decide�.

[Designer footwear]

Hello. Great job. I did not expect this on a Wednesday. This is a great story. Thanks!

[Benchmark Advertising]

Great article, Lori.
And for myself, I don't agree on that to be legal.

[H Miracle Review]

The post is very intellectually written, with lots of valuable information

[Merchant Cash Advance]

This is absolutely optional. But I agree that, this decision is very confusing among dads.

[bill]

It really is pleasure to find out you, wishing the nicest issues generally to suit your needs, not merely nowadays, but every one of the 12 months by way of given that you may be seriously a delight to understand.

[No Credit Check Payday Loans]

Wow this is really interesting. Touchy subject but I'd have to side with the father.

[torrent download]

When it was allowed by the Supreme Court, the plaintiff's unwanted child, who was born because his mother had no money for an illegal abortion or a trip to another state, has already reached the age of three.

[cheap jordans]

Lebron

James 3 Jeff Becker said that after authorities reviewed

videotape of the shooting, investigators determined that the

gunman, identified as Clay A. Duke, fatally shot himself after

being hit by shots fired by Jones.

[torrent download]

Heart is like a ground where you plant your feelings.

[Payday Loans]

This could start a worrying trend.

[Supra Thunder]

Weng Liju, Jiao Liya, Tang Xiaonai.

[cheap air yeezy]

Romance is seeking perfection, love is forgiving faults!

[cheap air yeezy]

Romance is seeking perfection, love is forgiving faults!

[Jordan Blase]

The top type of close friend is a style it is possible to sit on a porch and swing with, under no circumstances say a phrase, after which stroll away feeling like it was one of the best conversation you’ve ever had.

[coach outlet]

nothing is impossible for a willing heart.

[viagra online]

In 1973 the U.S. Supreme Court attempted to resolve this conflict in a given case. When it was allowed by the Supreme Court, the plaintiff's unwanted child, who was born because his mother had no money for an illegal abortion or a trip to another state, has already reached the age of three. The whole point of the process is to test the constitutionality of legislation in Texas to ban abortions, except when continuing the pregnancy threatens a woman's life...Thank you guys...

[Viagra Online]

Theoretically the sperm donor is actually the dad, but it was not responsable of the use of it. He would be responsable if he was aware of that his sperm will be used for inseminating a determinate woman. It is a tricky issue.

[repossessed cars]

Political Correctness gone absolutely bonkers!