Should Infant DNA Later Be Used in Forensics?

By Lori Andrews

Since the 1960s, public health departments around the globe have tested hospitalized newborn babies for serious genetic disorders, generally without the parents' knowledge or consent.  Many departments save that DNA, tiny spots of blood on paper.  Now questions have arisen about whether law enforcement officials should have access to those samples.  In other words, should babies have a right not to self-incriminate themselves?

In the United States, an Institute of Medicine committee recommended that DNA banks created for medical and research purposes (such as newborn screening banks) not be used for forensic purposes.  But, in other countries, courts have handled fascinating cases on route to setting policies.

Controversy arose in Sweden when the authorities in charge of the newborn screening samples allowed access to police without an order from a court.  In 2003, Sweden's Foreign Minister, Anna Lindh, was fatally stabbed in a department store.  Police investigators did not find a match between the DNA left behind by the assassin and the national criminal database.  So they turned to another DNA database, the PKU biobank, which has collected blood samples of all newborns in Sweden since 1975 as a medical resource.  The police arrested a man who had been identified by the newborn screening DNA bank.

Afterwards, the National Board on Health and Welfare (a Swedish governmental agency) investigated the delivery of the samples to the police and found that the Biobanks in Medical Care Act gave an individual "absolute control" over the future possible use of a saved sample.  The Board criticized the biobank for being "more compliant with the police than was necessary" and for not trying the question in court.  The Board suggested that the privacy concerns in the Biobanks in Medical Care Act should have precedence over the confiscation of samples for use in forensics.

Sweden went one step further and allowed people to have their newborn samples destroyed.  When law enforcement officials sought to obtain the names of all people who had taken their samples out of the biobank, a court refused, since the removal of samples was not proof that the people were guilty of anything.

In Western Australia, the police obtained a search warrant allowing them to seize children's newborn screening cards from the hospital after the mother refused to let her children undergo blood tests in an incest case.  The test results helped lead to a successful conviction.  At the time, there were no laws protecting the database.  Public concern that participation in the program would decrease led the Western Australia Health Department to adopt a policy requiring the cards to be destroyed after two years.  Other Australian states, including New South Wales and Victoria, have subsequently adopted Memorandums of Understanding limiting police access of newborn screening blood samples.  The New South Wales policy allows access to screening cards only to identify human remains or to identify samples from a crime scene that police believe are from a missing victim.  The police are required to make a reasonable effort to contact the next of kin or a parent to obtain consent except when doing so would be impracticable or would compromise an ongoing investigation.  The Victoria policy requires specific court authority through a court order.

Newborn screening programs serve an important health purpose.  Infants identified with the disease PKU can be treated, staving off mental retardation.  But access of other institutions to the samples can undermine faith in the program.  Newborn screening samples should be destroyed two years after collection unless the parents are told of all possible future uses and then consent.

Comments

[employees payroll]

If we use it, it could make more crime to fill the demand. Just my guess, it may not happen.

[coach handbags]

Good is good and bad is bad
You don't know which one you had
She put your books out on the sidewalk
Now they're blowing 'round

[dinariraqiedu]

If we use it, it could make more crime to fill the demand. Just my guess, it may not happen

This is wonderful article.I like this show, i recommend to other for like this.
Iraqi Dinar

[free answering website]

Don't know what is wrong what is rite but i know that every one has there own point of view and same goes to this one..

[New Balance Sneakers]

Life finds its wealth by the claims of the world, and its worth by the claims of love.Do you understand?

[Consignment]

How-do-you-do, just needed you to know I have added your site to my Google bookmarks because of your extraordinary blog layout. But seriously, I think your site has one of the freshest theme I've came across. It really helps make reading your blog a lot easier.

[Seo India]

Chemically, DNA consists of two long polymers of simple units called nucleotides, with backbones made of sugars and phosphate groups joined by ester bonds. These two strands run in opposite directions to each other and are therefore anti-parallel. Attached to each sugar is one of four types of molecules called bases. It is the sequence of these four bases along the backbone that encodes information. This information is read using the genetic code, which specifies the sequence of the amino acids within proteins.If you have need any helps of seo services then you may contact at a good seo services for promote you business . We always helps you. You can use our seo services offers to rank your website into top 3 positions on Google , Yahoo , MSN and other search engines .

[ffxiv gil]

I have added your site to my Google bookmarks because of your extraordinary blog layout. These two strands run in opposite directions to each other and are therefore anti-parallel. Attached to each sugar is one of four types of molecules called bases. It is the sequence of these four bases along the backbone that encodes information.

[EssieSloan]

Houses are not cheap and not everybody can buy it. However, credit loans are invented to help people in such kind of situations.

[E cigarette]

I have liked your thoughts, I am going to subscribe your blog and will come here again
to know more. thanks,

E cigarette

[magic of making up]

i think we all should have our own dna taken for future uses. so that we can also study the depth of the human body and psychosis.

[Louis Vuitton]

It is nice to find a site about my interest. My first visit to your site is been a big help. Thank you for the efforts you been putting on making your site such an interesting and informative place to browse through. I'll be visiting your site again to gather some more valuable information. You truly did a good job.
http://www.louisvuitton8.com/

[San Diego SEO]

I think it should be the parents choice.

[ugg boots]

I just walk around, suprised by your blog,please give more information.

[air max 90]

*Love is ever the beginning of knowledge as fire is of light.!@

[air max 90]

*Love is ever the beginning of knowledge as fire is of light.!@

[weimaraner obedience advice]

Fantastic... what a wonderful idea...

[Terran Build Orders]

I totally agreed with you that newborn screening program did play a more important role in modern medial history. And I think DNA banks as you mentioned for medical or research purposes, especially for newborn DNA banks, should not be used for forensic purposes.

[Sguf]

Perfectly combining cozy, warm with fashion together, the UGG Adirondack Boots provide a stylish approach to dressing for snowy, wet conditions.

[Kgdys]

UGG Broome Boot is a handsome knee-high boot with a great contemporary, simplified yet stylish look. Especially fit for tall girls, these boots perfectly go well with shorts and skirts make you be the fashion talk around town.

[debt relief]

Another thing that people should do is weight their options when it comes to paying off debt, debt relief, debt settlement and / or bankruptcy

[Outdoor Shed Plans]

I think storing anonymous DNA data for disease prevention and healthcare improvement is acceptable but for the DNA data to be made available to other agencies is unacceptable. At some stage it will get to the point where there are so many copies of your DNA available that it's validity in crime detection will be questioned.

[Peluang Usaha]

Maybe the DNA can be use full as one of the resourches

[fat burning furnace review]

This is interesting, Personally I Think DNA could be very useful here.

[how to start a clothing line]

Its really up to the individual parents in what they want.